The True DarkSiders Theory Everyone’s Been Too Afraid to Share! - Abbey Badges

Understanding the Context

What Is the DarkSiders Theory Everyone’s Fearful to Speak?

At the heart of this unspoken theory lies a startling revelation: the protagonists of DarkSiders are not heroes, but unwitting pawns in an ancient, cosmic war between powerful fallen angels and primordial forces. Most players have swallowed the narrative that the DarkSiders fight evil to save humanity, but proponents of this controversial theory argue that the truth is darker, far less heroic, and disturbingly real.

In essence, the theory suggests that the save-war waged by the DarkSiders isn’t humanity’s salvation—it’s a desperate ploy orchestrated by ancient forces manipulating mortals to fight a battle that impacts realms beyond human comprehension. Some even claim the characters themselves are possessed vessels or altered beings, conduits designed to trigger a prophecy that dismantles spiritual balances for unknown purposes.

Key Insights

Why This Theory Gets Shy Whispers

One major reason this theory has never been openly discussed is the depth of its implications. Supporting it often requires re-examining beloved characters through a lens of cosmic horror. For instance:

• Metatrusted’s cryptic motives have long intrigued fans. While widely interpreted as redemption, the true theory proposes he is a pawn acting not for freedom, but enforcing a hidden scheme.
  
• Hellraisation’s origins—often seen as a force of primal darkness—are framed not as evil, but as a necessary force awakening to fulfill an arc that predates human civilization.
  
• The Night Angelion and the celestial conflict seem less about victory and more about manipulation—an interplanetary chess game where humanity is a pawn.

By embracing this theory, fans confront unsettling ideas about free will, destiny, and manipulation—concepts far darker than the game’s surface. For many, that discomfort explains why it remains mostly whispered in forums and private Discords.

Final Thoughts

The Evidence (and Why It’s Not Conclusive)

Supporters point to subtle in-game clues:

• The mutation curses plaguing characters aren’t just consequences of battle but may be symbolic of an external influence altering their essence.
  
• Dialogue from figures like King Stephen and the Manticora priesthood hints at prophecies involving “chosen ones” who unite not to defeat darkness, but to begin its rise.
  
• The DarkSiders’ fragmented split between hero and villain suggests a duality that defies simple morality—supporting the idea of dualistic forces beyond human morality.

Of course, canonical lore doesn’t confirm these ideas. But to die-hard fans, the dissonance is too unsettling to ignore.

Why This Theory Matters for the DarkSiders Legacy

The true fear behind this theory isn’t just about altering a beloved game’s story—it’s about confronting uncomfortable realities. DarkSiders shines brightest not only for its martial combat and gothic setting but for its exploration of power, sacrifice, and identity. Aversion to the deeper theory reveals a deeper truth: some mysteries are best left unspoken, for they challenge the core farewell—heroism itself.